Nick Clegg has a very difficult political game of chess to play, but he can go for checkmate if he wishes.
He is indeed much more popular in the country than members of Labour would like to admit. A recent YouGov survey found that just 20 per cent of people say Ed Miliband is performing well as Labour leader, while 21 per cent think the same of Nick Clegg as leader of the Liberal Democrats, despite his party’s unpopularity.
Tim Montgomerie has produced an article in the popular grassroots blog ‘Conservative Home’, warning David Cameron that it has been a mistake to put the NHS at the centre of the political debate. Montgomerie has indeed used the term ‘potentially fatal’ in describing the potential impact of the Bill on the future electoral chances of the Conservative Party in 2015.
The poll ratings of the Liberal Democrats have been consistently poor recently. In June 2011, an ICM poll reported that the Liberal Democrats have plummeted in the public’s opinion suffering a 14-year low with a score of 12 per cent.
Nick Clegg has been important in enabling important amendments to the proposed Bill. For example, in May 2011, he opposed to the surprise of many the competition regulator. He also publicly criticised David Cameron for declaring his love for the NHS while taking advice from people talking up the potential for private profits.
Nick Clegg has been remarkably loyal to the Coalition, having pledged an ‘united coalition’ in that famous rose garden scene on 12 May 2010, vowing to provide ‘strong and stable leadership’. Clegg has repeatedly emphasised the function of the Coalition as acting ‘in the national interest’.
However, many interested parties have now united instead against the NHS Health and Social Care Bill, including the Royal College of GPs, Faculty of Public Health, British Medical Association, Royal College of Nursing and Royal College of Midwives, which all oppose the bill outright.
Interestingly, Tim Farron MP, seen as a critical figure within the Liberal Democrats, has voiced his concerns, stating clearly this was not a Bill that the Liberal Democrats would have introduced if they had been in power on their own. He added: “What we’ve done is to prevent the worst excesses, to stop the emphasis on competition and put the emphasis on quality. I guess my largest complaint is that it has taken 12 months and it has taken people’s eye off the ball when it comes to delivering health care at the chalk face.”
This political game of chess for Nick Clegg is therefore an extremely complicated one. If his party supports the Bill, he could be supporting legislation modernising the management of the NHS ‘in the national interest’. However, many MPs and activists from various parties have warned that this Bill is no longer fit for any purpose.
If Liberal Democrat MPs are successfully whipped to recommend the Bill for enactment, the popularity of David Cameron is very unlikely to be affected. Ed Miliband will have been handed a gift for the 2015 general election, and the Liberal Democrats might achieve their lowest poll rating ever. Despite the national interest, does Nick Clegg wish this to be his lasting legacy for the Liberal Democrats?
If, on the other hand he decides to urge his party to oppose the Bill, he will have strengthened the importance of the Liberal Democrats in the Coalition, and may indeed have done England a big favour. That might be a more fitting legacy.
